Drug Education News

News and views from the Drug Education Forum

Heroin is hard work. You don’t drift into it

Martin Samuel writing in the Times argues that blaming celebrities for young people’s drug use doesn’t hold water:

It is a myth, the impressionability of teenagers where the deadliest drugs are concerned. Nobody becomes a casual heroin user. It is too much like hard work. It is the most determined act you will attempt all year.

I’m reminded that in 2006 a reporter from the same paper rang me up to see if I’d link what they saw as the rise in cocaine use by young people to a celebrity.  I declined, but the story was written, with Professor Furedi making the connection, and the Guardian’s Bad Science column taking the reporting to task a few days later.

Harry Shaperio writing on the DrugLink blog earlier this year pointed out that the links between what celebrities do and the way that young people behave is probably not central to drug misuse by that age group.  But as an earlier paper by the National Collaberating Centre for Drug Prevention, The Effects of Drug use by Celebrities upon Young People’s Drug Use and Perceptions of Use, points out the amount of research in this area means we’re working somewhat in the dark:

It must not be assumed however that the increased visibility of celebrity drug use goes hand in hand with influencing young peoples activities and opinion formation; such statements must be supported by good quality research, applicable to UK audiences.  Reception of media images is increasingly documented within theory as an active process in which meaning is constructed in the context of peoples’ own knowledge and experiences. There is a need, within both policy and research to objectively expand our understanding of this process in the context of celebrity behaviour, and the effect this has on the lives of young people. Little is known as to the relative effects of young peoples’ reception of positive and negative depictions of drug use within the media. UK based research is required to ascertain whether media depictions of drug use, help affirm or abate effective drug prevention strategies, taking on board the contemporary developments in media and viewing outlined within this paper.

Where we are on more solid ground is the description of risk and protective factors that influence the likelihood of young people developing long term problems with drugs, and liking particular celebrities hasn’t yet been added to that list.

Advertisements

Filed under: celebrity

3 Responses

  1. Oh dear! Does that long winded hypothesis beginning ‘it must not be assumed’ mean that young people do not seek to emulate their ‘heros’?

  2. drugeducationforum says:

    Yes, broadly I think it does.

  3. Sam says:

    Peter you have made a common mistake in confusing the word ‘celebrity’ with the word ‘hero’. Amy Winehouse (for example) is a regular staple of the Daily Mail’s gossip pages but you’d be wrong to think that this makes her a hero figure for the majority of young people. Most young people i know see her as a pretty sad figure, the most common emotion she evokes in them is one of wishing her well and seeking to look after (if they do take much notice of her at all – they seem to have much more interesting role models to be concerned about) her rather than copying her behavour. This seems to me to be what the quote is saying. Just cos it’s long winded don’t mean it ain’t worth reading.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Archives

%d bloggers like this: